Matt and Sean break down Spock's slide back to his ancestors' passions in Star Trek TOS Season 3, Episode 23, "All Our Yesterdays." Stranded in an ice age, Spock finally pushes back on years of digs from McCoy. The brothers single out that moment as one of the best Spock and McCoy scenes. They also unpack what it says about Vulcan logic.
Order Sean’s next book, “In the Fields We Thirst” here: https://undecided.link/in-the-fields-we-thirst
Chapters
- 00:00 - Intro
- 02:07 - Mailbag
- 09:22 - Episode Description
- 09:58 - This Time in History
- 12:19 - Episode Discussion
Transcript
Intro
Sean Ferrell: In today's episode of Trek in Time, we're talking about what it means to be trapped in your own past. Welcome, everybody, to Trek in Time. This is the podcast that takes a look at Star Trek in original chronological stardate order. And we've just finished our jump in of Strange New Worlds season four. We hope you'll be interested in going back and checking that out if you didn't join us for that. But right now we are literally two episodes away from finishing our rewatch of the original series, which means the movies are right around the corner. And then after that, it's going to be barely Christmas and we're going to be watching Next Generation, which that's the gift that keeps on giving. As far as my brother is concerned, yes, this podcast is a pair of brothers. I'm Sean Ferrell. I'm a writer. I write some sci fi, write some horror. As a matter of fact, I have a book coming out in April in the Fields We Thirst. It's a horror novel set in World War I. There'll be information in the notes below. Hope you'll be interested in checking that out. With me, as always, is my brother Matt. He is that Matt behind Undecided with Matt Ferrell, which takes a look at emerging tech and its impact on our lives. Matt has just traveled. So, Matt, how is the jet lag? Did you have the jet lag? Are you in the jet lag? What do you think about jet lag?
Matt Ferrell: I think I'm in the jet lag. Cause I literally got off the plane. Sean, what is it? Two hours ago.
Sean Ferrell: Oh, wow. Okay. Didn't realize that.
Matt Ferrell: Yeah,
Sean Ferrell: yeah. I just got off of a subway train. No big whoop. So today,
Matt Ferrell: is there train lag?
Sean Ferrell: We're going to be talking. Yeah. In New York City there is. Today we're going to be talking about the original series episode all our Yesterdays. This is episode number 23 from season three of the original series. It's the 78th produced. The 78th aired, and as I mentioned, the 23rd of the third season. It originally broadcast on March 14, 1969. And we'll also be talking about that day in history, because that's what we do here. We visit the episode. We also visit the time that it was originally broadcast. But before we get into that, we always like to hear what you've had to say about our recent episodes. So what have you found in the mailbag for us this week, Matt?
Mailbag
Matt Ferrell: Well, there's a couple interesting themes from episode 246, Requiem from Methuselah. We have a comment from Rebecca Terry who wrote, I have always enjoyed this episode and I still rewatch it. However, I totally agree with the criticism of Kirk falling, quote, madly in love with the girl. That act with Kirk as a heartthrob in nearly every episode is too much for me and those scenes are hard to watch. Overall, I still like this one and I do really love the ending with Spock and Kirk. And I wanted to bring this one up because there was a theme of a bunch of people, no matter what they thought about the rest of the episode, were just like, love that scene with Spock and Kirk at the end. So they're right there with you, Sean.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah, that's a standout for me, that scene.
Matt Ferrell: Then we had one from Lone Locust. I'm kind of surprised that you didn't mention that. Jerome Bixby, who wrote this episode, went on later to make an excellent little sci fi film called The Man from Earth, which re spins the premise of this episode. Ancient immortal man making his way through history. And all done in the premise of a farewell dinner party. Also, no sex bot ick factor. And one of the stars is John Billingsley. Highly recommend you watch it. I think I've seen that, but it's been so long I think I memory wiped myself. But have you seen it?
Sean Ferrell: It is on a list of films I want to watch over this past summer, starting in the spring and through the summer, I started putting together a pretty big list of sci fi and horror films. A lot of them independent, a lot of them smaller, a lot of them cult favorites. And that film popped up as one of those films on that list. I did not realize that it was by this Mr. Bixby. So that's very interesting. It's also interesting that John Billingsley is in it because, you know,
Matt Ferrell: I know he's.
Sean Ferrell: He's a favorite of ours.
Matt Ferrell: So Mark Loveless had a comment around the nostalgia factor of Star Trek, the original series because I brought that up in that episode of like, I think you have a stronger nostalgia for the original series than I do. For me it's Next Generation. For you it's the original series.
Sean Ferrell: And
Matt Ferrell: Mark Loveless wrote Agree with Sean feeling verklempt. However, I do think I also am somewhat sympathetic to flaws in the Star Trek the original series because of nostalgia, their budgets, 60s overacting, and by God, it was the absolute best sci fi on television one could be exposed to during that time, even in reruns. I mean, for example, Lost in Space.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah.
Matt Ferrell: The standards started to change when the space movies started getting better, like 2001 A Space Odyssey, but it took a while for the higher quality to reach television. Things slowly got better until Star Wars and Alien came out and blew the lid off the genre. I do agree with him on the timescale there because like when I started to get really into sci fi on film and tv, it was around that time period of where I was seeing Alien on HBO, non stop repeat those kind of things.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah, yeah, I completely agree with Mark. That's like just to add it, just to add to that. I think that I remember our mom trying to introduce me to Lost in Space in a rerun. And I was a kid.
Matt Ferrell: Yeah.
Sean Ferrell: And I was, I was a fan of Star Trek and she was like, if you like Star Trek, you'll like this too. And showed me an episode of Lost in Space and I was like, what is this hot mess? This, this is might as well be the Brady Bunch. It was just, it didn't make any sense. Me. So for me it was Star Trek and then, and then below that was Space 1999. Which. Space 1999 has episodes that are fairly unwatchable because it just evolved into people in goofy costumes being chased around. But it still had that endeavor to be like, we're trying to be smart when we can be smart. So yeah, Mark, the best sci fi, even in reruns until like you said, Star wars suddenly opened up avenues to storytelling that up to that point had been relegated to the rerun. So
Matt Ferrell: yeah,
Sean Ferrell: well said.
Matt Ferrell: And then finally from sparkling tacos. So will you be watching the Orville after Next Generation Season 7 or before Deep Space Nine? I wanted to read this one because people keep bringing up really good shows and movies to watch. Like the joke about we should watch Stargate SG1. And I'm actively doing that right now with my wife and I love that show. And I think the Orville is like some of the best Star Trek that's been created in years. And I don't know if you've seen it yet, Sean. Have you watched it yet?
Sean Ferrell: I have seen, I've seen scenes and I feel like I watched, I feel like I watched the pilot and I didn't dislike it and I haven't disliked the scenes I've seen. But, but it's one of those shows that there's so much good stuff on television and there's so little time to make room for new programs that it's one of those programs that just kind of stands. I'm very aware of it and I'm very aware of the respect that it gets. It's an interesting question to, like, where would you put it in a rewatch? Little peek into what Matt and I have been talking about. The entire point of this podcast is to be watching these in chronological stardate order. So when it comes to Next Generation, there is no after Next Gen. Next gen is going to be shuffled in with Deep Space Nine and Voyager, which is going to be interesting. It's going to be a really interesting way to watch this. So it would be a question of, if we were to try to fit that in, would we shuffle that in as well? Do we maybe do a special standalone episode in which we watch a few episodes of it and talk about it as a show in general? I don't know. Maybe we do something like that. There's also the movie rewatch in which we could argue, like, do we watch Galaxy Quest? So that's.
Matt Ferrell: Yeah, that definitely.
Sean Ferrell: Like, do we watch the original series movies and then watch Galaxy Quest as a kind of capper? So.
Matt Ferrell: So I don't know. When Sean, when you and I discussed doing this podcast, what feels like a thousand years ago, one of the reasons I got super excited about doing this was specifically the Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, Voyager. Watching in chronological order is never a way I ever watched those shows, and it's gonna be really interesting to see if it changes how I perceive those shows in any way and how they interrelate. And we're 250 episodes into our show. We still.
If you haven't gotten there yet, I find that so funny. The part I'm most excited for, we're still probably a year away from.
Sean Ferrell: I remember when we talked about it, and it was. It was four years ago now. That was part of the big sales pitch of, like, wouldn't it be fun to do that? And the only time we've done it is when we've literally interrupted that plan to watch new shows. So it's like we've shuffled in other programs, but not because they fit into the timeline. It's because they're brand new. We want to watch them now and talk about them now. So I'm really looking forward to that. But before we get there, we got other fish to fry. Those lights you see those alarms you hear, that's not Matt falling in love with the idea of the podcast. It is time for him to tackle. I'm sorry, this is a Wikipedia description. So take it away, Matt. Okay.
Episode Description
Matt Ferrell: Captain Kirk, Spock, and Dr. McCoy are trapped in two time frames of another planet's past.
This Time in History
Sean Ferrell: When you put it like that, doesn't sound so bad. This episode originally dropped on March 14, 1969. And Matt, you'll never guess what. That's right. A lot of the cultural touchstones we've talked about in previous episodes, well, they're still active now. Yes. I'm talking about things like the top song being Everyday People by Sly and the Family Stone. Take it away, Matt. Little fun fact for all of you who have just while watching this on YouTube, saw the image from the record cover of Sly and the Family Stone. Matt has that outfit that Sly is wearing in that picture. And at the movies. Yes. Yet again, it was Funny Girl. Spoiler alert. This Barbara Streisand, Omar Sharif comedy is also going to be the last movie we talk about from the 60s as we end that part of this podcast next week. And on television, we've been looking at the top rated programs, but I decided this week, since we're so close to the end, instead to look at one of the lowest rated programs of 1969. And the result stunned me when I discovered, based on some research, what it was. It was a little program called the Brady Bunch. This show premiered in September of 1969, and despite running for five seasons, becoming one of the most recognizable shows in TV history. It never finished in the Nielsen top 30 during any of its seasons. Like Star Trek, it built its legacy in syndication. I think it's really remarkable.
Matt Ferrell: That's wild.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah. So the Brady Bunch is right up there with Star Trek as one of those programs that at the time people were like, yeah, this ain't really working. And in the news on this day in March 1969, hey, Matt, remember when we had a space program that regularly had people splashing down in the middle of the ocean? That's right, one of the Apollo launches. This is Apollo 9 return to Earth. So the New York Times front page was covered with images of the astronauts return. This was also the same mission that was referenced last week in which a spacewalk had taken place. At this point, the Apollo missions were replicating the amount of time it was going to take the Apollo missions to get to the moon and replicating the conditions of trying to do things like being outside of the capsules for extended periods of time in suits that they weren't completely sure wouldn't do things like, oh, I don't know, spring a leak. So on now to our discussion of this week's episode. All our yesterdays. We usually take a little, you know, back and forth, taking turns to talk about the episode first. I think I spoke first last time around. So do you want to launch off with your thoughts about this episode? I know how I feel about it and I will ask you a question as a jumping off point, which is probably going to give away my feelings, but I'm still going to do it a better episode this time around. Maybe a better way of ending the series than some of the previous episodes may have felt. How do you feel about this episode as a first, just as an episode, a story in and of itself and as a Star Trek episode as well.
Episode Discussion
Matt Ferrell: I actually like this one a lot. I wouldn't call it the best original series episode, but it's a good, solid Star Trek episode. And I thought it was very clever how they did it because I know their budget was next to nothing at this point.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah.
Matt Ferrell: And there was still a number of like new, what felt like new sets. But you know, they were recycled from stuff they had probably already done. And then all the costumes were clearly costumes from the, the movie studio of like, what do they got over here? Hey, they got people that look like they're from like France in the 1800s. Let's put them in that. So it, it felt. Had that feeling to it.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah.
Matt Ferrell: But it was a very clever use of it where they've done cost cutting episodes recently, which are just the dumbest possible plot and sci fi concept that you could come up with. Just a shoehorn, an excuse to like be in the wild West. Here they did it in a way that's like, oh well, this kind of makes sense. Here's a planet that's about to go get destroyed. They came up with a time travel technology to let them escape to their past. It's like, okay, that's, that's clever. That's, that's. Don't know if I completely understand. Like you can make time machines but you can't make rockets go zoom to another planet. Okay, okay. Not going to question it too much, but it was an interesting concept that they came up with. And the whole introduction with the, the librarian and it's like. And the librarian. And the librarian. He has these clones that are helping him to keep things under control. Very clever. Seems like really good kind of hard sci fi fun.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah.
Matt Ferrell: As well as the, the story goes places with the characters. It's like at the end of the episode I didn't have find myself going, what was the point of that? Which was basically the last couple of episodes I was like, what was the point of even telling this story? This one. It's like, oh, okay. We had some character development with Spock. We had Spock and McCoy, like their whole shtick that they were going through on that ice planet was really interesting. And Spock starting to kind of like, I don't know, like devolve into an older, more barbaric like Vulcan was a really interesting exploration. I thought the Kirk side of the storyline was actually the weakest part of the show, but at the same time still had fun with it. So I would give this one like a thumbs up. For me, it was a fun episode. I didn't regret watching it. I wasn't bored. And I thought, oh, this is, it's interesting. They had an episode that felt like it could have been from like the middle of season one, right near the end. That made me feel like, I wonder why they didn't make this the final episode. Because the title alone, like, if you knew this was gonna be your end, it's like all your yesterdays. It would have been a perfect like finale for the show. Just this title and this kind of concept of going into your past and re discovering yourself could have been really cool. But, ah, missed opportunities.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah. I wonder, I wonder how much of that is as a result of, as you pointed out, the Kirk storyline here is the weaker of the storylines and I wonder how much of this is. I remember what the final episode is and the final episode is a very keen spotlight on Kirk. So it's. I wonder how much of this is maybe them lining up scripts and saying like, well, let's, let's end on the big hero. Let's end on like giving Shatner a very key episode for, for his character. For this episode I agree with everything you've said. It's a, it's a fascinating episode from the perspective of opportunities missed, but missed because you don't have the room in a single episode to explore all the stuff that the episode suggests, which I like. That's the, for me, that's pulp sci fi, 60s sci fi, the cover of a book that looks like a beautiful painting of, you know, people in sleek astronaut gear heading toward a spaceship and like the imagination of like, what does that future look like? How do they jump off into that future and what does it entail? This episode feels very pulpy to me in that way, in that it hints at things that if they wanted to explore it further, could have created very interesting follow up episodes. At this point, Star Trek is not revisiting its own history in that way. But I couldn't help but think there's a part of me that's like, I have the feeling that there's probably a Star Trek novel that came out of this episode. Mr. Atox just seems like the perfect example of like they go to a. They go find another version of him and they go back into the library. Because I found myself thinking in terms of, like you said, this is a time travel fairing race, but not a space faring race. And they are the only planet around a single star. And I found myself thinking, okay, what kind of cosmology does this planet have? And of course, like you said, they produce an episode where they're like, let's go into the costume department and pull out costumes instead of making a new thing. But if you were to make a new thing, make new history around all of this, I found myself thinking, okay, you have the depiction of this single planet around this star that is going supernova.
Sean Ferrell: Is this a single planet where the people who evolved there evolved with a kind of narcissistic yeah, we're it. Why travel when this is it? We're exploring ourselves because there's nothing nearby to explore. We're only interested in us because we're all we have. So of course when it comes to escape, it turns into, well, we're going to go into our own past. And the idea of that as a generation of people who would then have to apparently pretend not to know their own history so that they wouldn't undo it, like the cosmology of that becomes really wild to think about. And I say that it's like I wrote a sci fi time travel novel where it's like that was kind of like, that's embedded in my interest. So like I watch this episode and I see a lot of subtext that I find fascinating. And the stuff that's not done in the episode as a result of just time restraints and budget restraints, I get it, I get why they don't pursue those avenues. But I like this episode because it gives me as a fan a lot of stuff to develop in my own headcanon of like really kind of like fun things. And it provided, I think, a kind of big picture touchstone that does feel like it became more known in other ways. Like this implies that part of the Vulcan's mindset is through contemporaneous existence of other Vulcans. Spock begins to devolve and McCoy is just like, what are your people doing on your planet right now? And he's like, they're barbaric and they're going against each other. They haven't yet developed the means of rescuing the civilization through the employment of logic. It implies that Spock is somehow tapped into a greater telepathic reinforcement of logic focus. And I find that interesting. I find that fascinating. And that is something that's hinted at in other episodes where Spock experiences the death of a ship of Vulcans. If you remember in the one with the giant space amoeba. And he's like, they were all confused, they didn't understand what was happening to them and they all died in utter disbelief. So it's this kind of like you take Spock out of time, he loses that reinforcement. And I think it's really, really cool. But it raises all these kind of cosmology questions. I like the episodes for its relationship building between Spock and McCoy by themselves. McCoy's empathy towards Spock, his love and care for Spock is in the foreground in a way that isn't often seen in the episodes where the two of them just kind of bicker. And, and I remember this episode from when I was a kid of enjoying the Kirk part of it because it's an identifiable witch trial scare of, you know, everybody around it was just like, well, he's. There were voices, he responded to them. He must be a witch. And the moment that the judge is revealed to also be a time traveler and he. Because when he responds to the word the library. And I remember as a kid being stunned, I was just like, oh my God, I can't believe he's also from a different time. And I remember, I remember the, the surprise of that, that element in what is otherwise. It just kind of like action based part of the story. It's just there to show like some swashbuckling, some running around, some sword play. Like it's fine for what it is, but it also, it's entertaining. And like you said, it's doing something that the previous episodes didn't do, which is it seems to have a point and it seems to have a. It has an opinion. Whereas some of the previous episodes feel very much like, well, we've got to go out and tap dance for you for 40 minutes. It's just tap dancing. There's nothing here other than us dancing.
Matt Ferrell: There's also a scene like I read the comments about people loving that scene between Spock and Kirk, that very touching thing of here's a friend wanting to stop his other friend from hurting and how so many people love that scene. There's a scene in this one that I was like, I did not remember, but when it happened, it Hit me of like, oh, wow, that's a great scene where McCoy is doing his normal. I don't want to say his bigoted Vulcan humor, but where he's like, the digs that he constantly does at Spock, he does one of them and Spock leans forward and in a very kind of menacing way, says, I don't think I like that. You know what? I've never liked that. And he says that it's such a cutting, like, it cuts deep. And not only is McCoy's performance, like, the performance of him reacting to that, like he's shocked, it's like, why is Spock showing emotion? But also, like, almost a recognition of, like, oh, crap, maybe I have been. I've been
Sean Ferrell: crossing a line. Yeah,
Matt Ferrell: I've been crossing a line and I haven't cared because I don't see Spock as having feelings, but clearly there's feelings there and it's been rubbing him the wrong way. It's like you could almost see in McCoy's face of like, oh, God, like, I don't realize. I didn't realize what I had been doing. At the same time as, why is Spock showing emotions at all? This is kind of scary. So I thought that entire sequence was very. I found it touching because it was just this two friends having this raw emotion on the surface and having this, like, realization and kind of cathartic moment of getting it out in the air, I thought was a really great scene.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah. It also. One of the things that happens in. To return to the idea of the bigger history that's hinted at here. And this goes back, I think, for me, to when the show was produced. Here we are in 1969. The show's gonna be a 1969 program, but it does certain things that hints that Star Trek is willing to wrestle with those hard concepts. And if this episode was made in 2026, I think it would lean even more into it in ways that we're familiar with from, like, Strange New Worlds, because Marriott Hartley, fine actress, she's likable. She used to do these TV commercials where she sold film with James Garner. And it was a very cute will they, won't they? Sort of set up of TV commercials. She is there because she is effectively a political prisoner, which,
Matt Ferrell: yeah,
Sean Ferrell: is really remarkable. And she refers to the person who sent his adversaries back in time to a place where he could honestly claim, I didn't kill them, but when are they? And how awful that is. It is this absolutely intentionally cruel means of treating people. And I found myself thinking in 1969 for them to depict that as a political act. Here we are in 1969, Vietnam is still going on. It is a key element of the presidential race that had just taken place in 68. You've had two major political figures in RFK who arguably would have had a very good chance of defeating Nixon in a campaign for the presidency, assassinated and Martin Luther King Jr. And you had the Democratic National Convention in which the race riots that took place outside were a stark reminder of the strife that was going on in the country, as well as things like the Kent State shootings had just recently happened. And here you have an episode of Star Trek in which they are saying this despotic ruler would put political prisoners out of history. Literally just remove them from the current timeline so that those voices would no longer exist. I found that to be a really interesting stance for Star Trek to take in this moment. I think if it was a show that was produced now, they might have been bolder in depicting where Kirk goes in a different way. Because imagine if this episode. I'm going to do a soft rewrite here, not because I think the episode is weak, but just because I think what an amazing episode it would have been if Kirk had gone back to that era where the political actions of the ruler were that, as opposed to going back to some witchcrafty era of, well, it's a quasi French Revolution, ancient medieval England sort of depiction. But if the Kirk storyline was.
He's in that era where political voices are being disappeared and the ideas of freedom of speech and the ability to protest are being questioned, how it would have created a much tighter circle between the A story and the B story, where they would have really been informing each other of. You're seeing what vanquish looks like by the voices of innocent people. Because she isn't even a political prisoner because of anything she did. It's because of what some. Somebody in her family did. And you're seeing what vanquish looks like and then on the other side seeing what the society is struggling with. And I think that. Not that there was a missed opportunity, I don't think they wanted to go that deep into it. But it felt to me like, oh, if you did a little bit of massaging in this episode, you really would have been talking about 1968. And it still feels like it's referencing 1968, but it's doing in a very oblique way. So this is one of those episodes where I feel like, as opposed to some of the things we've just recently talked about on this podcast. This episode really does feel like it's talking about the era. It does feel like it's talking about, like, how do you. How do you live in your history when your history has hard things to know, when it has those elements that you don't want to embrace but you have to accept? And what do you do when you revisit those moments in history and have to look at them in order to know that you can make it forward? It's literally a society living its future by going to its past. And that's not often done. It wasn't really done in the 1960s. It's not being done now. Like, the challenges of those who don't know history are doomed to repeat. It turned into a Sci Fi episode effectively and. And done in a way. In a way, like you've. You've said and I've said. I remember watching this one fondly as a kid.
I enjoyed watching it now as an adult. This is one where when I, when we got to it, I was like, oh, thank goodness we're going to be able to watch an episode that we're not going to sit there and just be like, oh, my God, this. And why was the Klingon in blackface? Like. Like, that didn't feel like that at all. Yeah, So
Matt Ferrell: I was gonna say big picture. This one was a good one. There were still things in it that drove me a little nuts, but they were like little nothing burgers, like, not a big deal.
Sean Ferrell: Yeah, I found myself forgiving those. Those elements that were just like, okay, this is kind of like, that's kind of a goofball thing. But,
Matt Ferrell: yeah,
Sean Ferrell: those things were typically. Because, like, well, it's a production for the 1960s, like they were making. It was a show that's going to be dated, and it's going to be a show that in some cases is going to be a little silly. But overall, I found myself thinking like, okay, this one for season three. I put this one in the upper echelon of episodes for season three, as opposed to what we've been going through for the past few weeks, which has felt like we're watching things, that there was barely a script, and so this one felt like a breath of fresh air. So, viewers, listeners, what did you think about this one? Did you think that it gets better marks because it's tells a more challenging story and it's fairly well told? Or do you think that this one is one that you'd prefer to skip and pretend was sent off into some Ice Age cave? Where you never had to think about it ever again. Let us know in the comments. As always, liking, subscribing, sharing with your friends, and commenting. Those are all the very easy ways for you to support the podcast. If you want to support us more directly, you can go to trekintime.Show. Click the join button. Not only does it allow you to throw coins at our heads, it also makes you an Ensign, which means you'll be signed up for our spin off show, Out of Time, in which we talk about things that don't fit within the confines of this program. We hope you'll be interested in checking that out. Thank you so much everybody for taking the time to watch or listen, and we'll talk to you next time for the last episode of the original series.
Member discussion: